Thanks to the persuasive powers of David Meerman Scott, I decided to take a work day to attend a Vice-President Biden rally in New Hampshire – his first. One of the advantages of living nearby in Massachusetts is that you can easily get to this political hotspot and back in a day. David is once again making a marketing study of the strategies and techniques of the various candidates, and he likes to attend many of their personal appearances. He and his wife Yukari Watanabe have been to a dozen so far.
That’s no mean feat, either, as you’ll realize when you understand that in order to have any chance to get inside where the candidate is speaking, you have to show up at least an hour ahead of the published time. And then the odds are good that the show will be running late. It was an hour and a half after I arrived that the strains of the Beatles’ “Come Together” wafted through the pizzeria where the event was held, and after introductions by New Hampshire state representatives Tom Loughman and Mike Edgar, Joe finally took the stage. About an hour of that waiting time was standing outside in the unseasonably cold Spring weather we New Englanders have had so far.
My interest was in the speechmaking, of course, and so let’s cut to the verbal chase. How did the speakers do?
Tom Loughman is a pretty good speaker. He partly read his speech, but it was articulate and delivered with some panache. Mike Edgar was so nervous that he read his speech verbatim from a clipboard, and it was frankly a fairly weak performance.
And Joe? Sadly, I don’t think V-P Biden is ready – yet – for prime time. He rambled, got lost in his speech, frequently apologized for going on too long, and used the same stock phrases over and over again. He had a roomful of supporters and came close to losing his audience. There were only two applause lines in the entire speech. He needs to work on becoming much clearer, more vivid, and more concise in his remarks. He needs to tell better stories. His best moments were in his answers during the Q and A, and his best answer was when he talked about his father, fighting the abuse of power, and his sponsorship of the Violence Against Women Act.
His body language signaled his lack of focus: he wandered around the small stage area set aside for him, at random. Indeed, he turned his back on one woman who had asked a question as he got lost in his answer and rambled over to the other side of the room. She would have had every reason to feel snubbed. I don’t think he won her vote with that answer.
Mr. Biden is a transparently decent, kind, and honorable politician. His heart is obviously in the right place. But he needs to sharpen his oratory or he won’t be able to go the distance.
A few pics from the Vice President Biden event.
Joe preps while Mike Edgar introduces him.
Joe making his pitch to the NH crowd.
V-P Biden and this blogger!
Nick, Yukari and I enjoyed hanging out with you while we waited (and waited) for the show to start. The primary season is indeed strange, but we’re fortunate to live close to the action in New Hampshire!
While you focused on Biden’s speaking, I paid attention to how he engages with his fans. In that category, he is fabulously skilled. He has been a national-level public figure since being elected to the U.S. Senate at age 29 (almost 50 years ago) so he has certainly had practice.
Biden stuck around after the event concluded for nearly an hour to make sure everybody had a chance for a handshake or selfie. Each got a kind word and if asked a question, a thoughtful answer. His staff made a point of accommodating the several hundred people who couldn’t get into the main room in a side area where the talk was broadcast on TV screens. Biden made sure to visit the side area in person after the talk so everyone who wanted to could meet him. Very well played because each of those people are likely to share their selfie on social media influencing many thousands of other people.
Thanks for the comment, David. It will be very interesting to see how Biden’s personal touch fares once he’s out of the retail scene in NH and Iowa and has to go nationwide. Which will prove to be more important — rhetorical skills or marketing? If the last election cycle is any indication, marketing may trump the day!
Nick,
I have the same concerns about Biden as a speaker (having only seen him on TV, not live). He seems unfocused. He seems to begin almost every sentence with the words “Look” or “Folks” (or sometimes, “Look, folks…”). He rambles a lot and doesn’t always finish his thought. It occurred to me that if we end up with Trump vs. Biden, we may have the most inarticulate campaign ever! You seem to feel Biden can work to get better at speaking, but I wonder about that, at this stage. All of that said, I agree with David that Biden has some very strong qualities (seems honest, down to earth, savvy about world politics, and can connect with people on a human level) so my hope is that it will overcome his speaking deficiencies.
Thanks, Warren — Can you imagine the debate between Trump and Biden? It would be like that Garry Trudeau carton from a few years back, where the reporters were accosting a politician, saying, “A verb, Senator, a verb!” I think in that case Trudeau was poking fun at the late Senator Ted Kennedy. Inarticulateness lurks on both sides of the aisle.
I am surprised at what I am reading. I do not doubt it but I am surprised. I saw Mr. Biden speak at a conference in Toronto a couple of years ago and I was blown away by his delivery, his demeanor and his kind-heartedness. I hope he gets back to that form in time to make a difference.
Thanks for your comment, Michael — this was V-P Biden’s first campaign stop in NH, so I have real hope that he can sharpen his message and delivery as he gets into the process. Stay tuned!
Just did an article as a take-off from yours. Interestingly, there is another whole field of public speaking you may have not tapped — and which would benefit from some help – seminars – conferences!
Link: rhetoricandhomiletics.org/2019/05/18/rhetoric-homiletics-seven-lessons-from-v-p-joe-biden/
Thanks, Ted — great article, for anyone interested in following the comments.
I too am very disappointed at Joe Biden’s delivery. I expected a lot more from someone who has run for office multiple times. He ought to know how to make a crowd hang on to his every word. IMO, he is the worst of all the candidates running for office and I’m concerned he is topping the charts merely on name recognition. The job of the President, among others, is to rally the nation . My fear is that he may not even be able to rally enough people to vote for him.
Thanks, Olumide — you’re absolutely right — name recognition is likely driving most of Biden’s poll numbers. That will change as the race gets closer to real tests like Iowa and NH. Stay tuned!